# PNVA Robustness Evolution Report Date: 2026-05-05 Author: Gustavo de Aguiar Martins Project: PNVA-Core / Enygnalab / EnyOS ## Objective Evolve PNVA/no-tick toward a more sovereign and robust architecture without disturbing the validated PASS chain. ## What Was Preserved The following evidence remains intact: ```text 15m live gate PASS 8h live gate PASS 12h live gate PASS 24h live gate PASS canonical G1 stable opportunity PASS long-run-live-gate PASS guard rails PASS distribution-gate PASS production-candidate PASS ``` No runtime threshold was changed. No gate was reclassified. No raw local proof was published. ## What Was Added New sovereign layer: ```text schemas/pnva-event.schema.json schemas/pnva-entity.schema.json docs/PNVA_SOVEREIGN_LOGS_ENTITIES_HEURISTICS.md docs/PNVA_CANONICAL_EVENT_BRIDGE.md docs/PNVA_REPLAY_VALIDATION.md docs/PNVA_NO_TICK_INVARIANTS.md docs/PNVA_NATIVE_EVENT_EMITTER.md docs/PNVA_SOVEREIGN_POLICY_VALIDATION.md docs/PNVA_PROOF_CHAIN_SEALING.md docs/PNVA_CAUSAL_GRAPH_AUDIT.md docs/PNVA_SCHEMA_CONTRACT_VALIDATION.md docs/PNVA_CAUSAL_CHRONOLOGY_GUARD.md docs/PNVA_TENSION_DECISION_CALIBRATION.md docs/PNVA_DECISION_TRACE_INDEX.md docs/PNVA_HEURISTIC_INFLUENCE_MAP.md docs/PNVA_ENTITY_NO_TICK_MATRIX.md docs/PNVA_SUPPRESSION_LEDGER.md docs/PNVA_SOVEREIGN_ROBUSTNESS_GATE.md docs/PNVA_R3_MIGRATION_PLAN.md docs/PNVA_AUTHORITY_MIGRATION_LEDGER.md docs/PNVA_R3_AUTHORITY_PROJECTION.md docs/PNVA_R3_CUTOVER_GATE.md docs/PNVA_R3_RUNTIME_CAPTURE_MATRIX.md docs/PNVA_R3_RUNTIME_EVIDENCE_GUARD.md docs/PNVA_R3_RUNTIME_INSTRUMENTATION_PLAN.md docs/PNVA_R3_RUNTIME_CONTRACT_VALIDATION.md docs/PNVA_SOVEREIGN_EVOLUTION_LEDGER.md docs/PNVA_SOVEREIGN_EVIDENCE_ATTESTATION.md docs/PNVA_ADVERSARIAL_VALIDATION.md docs/PNVA_ENTITY_HEURISTIC_MATURITY.md docs/PNVA_SEMANTIC_CONSISTENCY_GUARD.md docs/PNVA_REPRODUCIBILITY_GUARD.md tools/pnva_sovereign_audit.py tools/pnva_canonical_bridge.py tools/pnva_replay_validator.py tools/pnva_no_tick_invariant_analyzer.py tools/pnva_native_event_emitter.py tools/pnva_sovereign_policy_validator.py tools/pnva_proof_chain_sealer.py tools/pnva_causal_graph_auditor.py tools/pnva_schema_contract_validator.py tools/pnva_causal_chronology_guard.py tools/pnva_tension_decision_calibrator.py tools/pnva_decision_trace_index.py tools/pnva_heuristic_influence_map.py tools/pnva_entity_no_tick_matrix.py tools/pnva_suppression_ledger.py tools/pnva_sovereign_robustness_gate.py tools/pnva_r3_migration_planner.py tools/pnva_authority_migration_ledger.py tools/pnva_r3_authority_projection.py tools/pnva_r3_cutover_gate.py tools/pnva_r3_runtime_capture_matrix.py tools/pnva_r3_runtime_evidence_guard.py tools/pnva_r3_runtime_instrumentation_plan.py tools/pnva_r3_runtime_contract_validator.py tools/pnva_sovereign_evolution_ledger.py tools/pnva_evidence_attestor.py tools/pnva_adversarial_validator.py tools/pnva_entity_heuristic_maturity.py tools/pnva_semantic_consistency_guard.py tools/pnva_reproducibility_guard.py reports/pnva-sovereign-audit-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-canonical-events-sample-2026-05-05.jsonl reports/pnva-entity-catalog-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-canonical-bridge-summary-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-replay-validation-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-no-tick-invariants-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-native-events-demo-2026-05-05.jsonl reports/pnva-native-entity-catalog-demo-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-native-emitter-summary-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-native-replay-validation-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-native-no-tick-invariants-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-sovereign-policy-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-native-sovereign-policy-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-proof-chain-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-native-proof-chain-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-causal-graph-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-native-causal-graph-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-schema-contract-validation-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-causal-chronology-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-tension-decision-calibration-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-decision-trace-index-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-heuristic-influence-map-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-entity-no-tick-matrix-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-suppression-ledger-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-sovereign-robustness-gate-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-migration-plan-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-authority-migration-ledger-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-summary-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-events-2026-05-05.jsonl reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-entities-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-replay-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-policy-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-no-tick-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-cutover-gate-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-runtime-capture-matrix-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-runtime-evidence-guard-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-runtime-instrumentation-plan-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-runtime-contract-validation-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-sovereign-evolution-ledger-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-sovereign-evidence-attestation-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-adversarial-validation-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-entity-heuristic-maturity-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-semantic-consistency-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-reproducibility-2026-05-05.json ``` ## Technical Diagnosis The local PNVA lab already has: ```text AdaptiveThreshold ETEV Guard Memory4D AffinityRouter PowerOrchestrator JSONL audit bundle PNVA event manager veonic heuristic logs production proof gates AI/search publication layer ``` Observed local log health: ```text pnva_decisions.jsonl 17525 lines, 0 JSON parse errors pnva-miner-events.jsonl 9427 lines, 0 JSON parse errors pnva_causal_events.jsonl 12735 sealed records zano_pnva_heuristics.jsonl 1845 heuristic records ``` Primary runtime pressure: ```text cpu_host_thermal_taper ``` Primary action: ```text RESIZE_BATCH ``` Interpretation: PNVA is acting conservatively. It is preserving no-tick/event-aware behavior, but the next intelligence layer must distinguish thermal provenance, worker capability and field tension more explicitly. ## Robustness Improvements ### 1. Canonical event envelope Old logs can now be mapped into: ```text pnva.event.v1 ``` This gives every event: ```text event_id causal_chain_id entity_id field state tension decision heuristics proof ``` ### 2. Canonical entity contract Every actor can now be described as: ```text pnva.entity.v1 ``` This prevents gates, workers, proofs, authors and publication pages from being mixed together. ### 3. Sovereign audit The new audit tool scores: ```text proof integrity AI/search discovery log contract readiness local log health sovereignty hygiene actionability ``` The audit does not rewrite history. It only reports structure, risk and readiness. ### 4. Canonical bridge Legacy JSONL logs can now be converted into the public `pnva.event.v1` envelope. Current sanitized bridge output: ```text event_count: 512 entity_count: 6 dominant action: RESIZE_BATCH dominant risk flags: RESIZE_BATCH_PRESSURE, THERMAL_PRESSURE, VEONIC_TRACE ``` This converts old lab evidence into a stable event contract without publishing raw local logs. ### 5. Replay validation The canonical sequence can now be replay-validated. Current replay result: ```text classification: REPLAY_VALID event_count: 512 unique_event_ids: 512 chain_count: 14 proof_hash_ok: 512 proof_hash_bad: 0 guard_pass_ok: 35 guard_block_ok: 33 errors: 0 ``` This means the public sample is not only formatted. It is internally checkable. ### 6. No-tick invariant analysis The no-tick invariant analyzer checks the stronger claim: PNVA records both execution and causal suppression. Current invariant result: ```text classification: SOVEREIGN_NO_TICK_READY event_count: 512 collapse_count: 266 observe_count: 213 block_count: 33 suppressed_count: 246 no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.4805 guard_consistency_ratio: 1.0 proof_integrity_ratio: 1.0 failed_invariants: 0 ``` This means the public sample contains proof-backed non-execution. In PNVA terms, the system does not simply sleep; it records why it did not collapse. ### 7. Native event emission The native emitter shows how a future PNVA runtime should emit canonical events directly. Current native result: ```text native emitter: NATIVE_EMITTER_READY native replay: REPLAY_VALID native no-tick invariants: SOVEREIGN_NO_TICK_READY event_count: 7 suppressed_count: 4 no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.5714 guard_consistency_ratio: 1.0 proof_integrity_ratio: 1.0 ``` This closes the next architecture gap: legacy logs remain useful through the bridge, but new runtimes can now be designed to emit `pnva.event.v1` from birth. ### 8. Sovereign policy validation The sovereign policy validator checks whether strong decisions have enough heuristic authority. Current canonical result: ```text classification: SOVEREIGN_POLICY_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS event_count: 512 strong_decision_count: 299 low_authority_legacy_count: 35 errors: 0 warnings: 35 ``` Current native result: ```text classification: SOVEREIGN_POLICY_READY event_count: 7 strong_decision_count: 5 low_authority_legacy_count: 0 errors: 0 warnings: 0 ``` This is intentionally honest. The old sample remains valid but carries legacy warnings. The native emitter is the clean path forward. ### 9. Proof-chain sealing The proof-chain sealer adds tamper evidence to event sequence order. Current canonical result: ```text classification: PROOF_CHAIN_SEALED event_count: 512 unique_event_ids: 512 proof_bad: 0 checkpoints: 9 ``` Current native result: ```text classification: PROOF_CHAIN_SEALED event_count: 7 unique_event_ids: 7 proof_bad: 0 checkpoints: 2 ``` This does not rewrite event history. It creates a public chain anchor where any content, proof or order mutation changes the final hash. ### 10. Causal graph audit The causal graph auditor exposes entity topology. Current canonical result: ```text classification: CAUSAL_GRAPH_READY event_count: 512 catalog_entity_count: 6 observed_entity_count: 6 chain_count: 14 relation_edge_count: 68 chain_edge_count: 230 errors: 0 warnings: 0 ``` Current native result: ```text classification: CAUSAL_GRAPH_READY event_count: 7 catalog_entity_count: 6 observed_entity_count: 6 chain_count: 1 relation_edge_count: 2 chain_edge_count: 6 errors: 0 warnings: 0 ``` This makes PNVA entity flow explicit: guards, workers, chains and relation edges become inspectable instead of remaining implicit log fields. ### 11. Schema contract validation The schema contract validator checks whether public `pnva.event.v1` and `pnva.entity.v1` records obey the structural contract. Current result: ```text classification: SCHEMA_CONTRACT_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS event_count: 519 entity_count: 12 relation_count: 70 heuristic_rule_count: 9 error_count: 0 warning_count: 341 ``` Scope result: ```text canonical: 512 events, 6 entities, 0 errors, 341 legacy warnings native: 7 events, 6 entities, 0 errors, 0 warnings ``` This hardens the evidence package at the log/entity boundary. The canonical bridge remains honest about legacy type-consolidation warnings, while the native path proves the production direction can be clean. ### 12. Causal chronology guard The causal chronology guard checks timestamp order, chain chronology and time-gap evidence. Current result: ```text classification: CAUSAL_CHRONOLOGY_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS event_count: 519 chain_count: 15 global_backward_count: 1 error_count: 0 warning_count: 2 native_chronology_clean: true ``` Scope result: ```text canonical: 512 events, 14 chains, 1 backward-time warning, 316 zero-gap batch records native: 7 events, 1 chain, 0 backward time, 0 zero-gap records, 0 warnings ``` This strengthens the post-temporal claim. PNVA does not use the clock as the blind execution driver, but it still preserves time as an auditable trace dimension. ### 13. Tension-decision calibration The tension-decision calibrator checks score, threshold, margin, gate_delta, guard events and decision semantics. Current result: ```text classification: TENSION_DECISION_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS event_count: 519 error_count: 0 warning_count: 384 native_calibration_clean: true legacy_calibration_warning_count: 384 ``` Scope result: ```text canonical: 512 events, 0 errors, 384 legacy calibration warnings native: 7 events, 0 errors, 0 warnings, calibrated clean ``` This hardens the no-tick claim at the decision layer. The native path now proves that collapse/block/observe/prove decisions are coherent with the tension field, while legacy bridge drift remains visible as warning evidence. ### 14. Decision trace index The decision trace index maps every public event to entity, heuristic rules, authority, tension and proof. Current result: ```text classification: DECISION_TRACE_INDEX_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS event_count: 519 traced_event_count: 519 trace_complete_count: 519 trace_coverage_ratio: 1.0 entity_coverage_ratio: 1.0 proof_coverage_ratio: 1.0 heuristic_coverage_ratio: 1.0 causal_chain_coverage_ratio: 1.0 tension_coverage_ratio: 1.0 hard_authority_event_count: 367 low_authority_trace_count: 152 hard_authority_ratio: 0.707129 error_count: 0 warning_count: 152 native_trace_clean: true ``` Scope result: ```text canonical: 512 events, trace coverage 1.0, 152 legacy low-authority trace warnings native: 7 events, trace coverage 1.0, 0 warnings, clean ``` This hardens the log and heuristic surface. Every public event now has a reviewer-facing trace path from event ID to actor, rule, authority, tension and proof. ### 15. Heuristic influence map The heuristic influence map quantifies rule influence by decision, authority, entity reach and proof coverage. Current result: ```text classification: HEURISTIC_INFLUENCE_MAP_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS event_count: 519 heuristic_rule_count: 9 heuristic_coverage_ratio: 1.0 proof_event_coverage_ratio: 1.0 influence_edge_count: 1136 hard_authority_edge_count: 776 low_authority_edge_count: 360 low_authority_strong_edge_count: 164 uncompensated_low_authority_strong_event_count: 35 hard_authority_edge_ratio: 0.683099 error_count: 0 warning_count: 70 native_influence_clean: true ``` Scope result: ```text canonical: 512 events, 1120 influence edges, 70 legacy warnings native: 7 events, 16 influence edges, 0 warnings, clean ``` This hardens the heuristic governance layer. Rule influence is now measurable by decision mix, entity reach, authority and proof coverage instead of remaining an opaque field inside event logs. ### 16. Entity no-tick matrix The entity no-tick matrix attributes suppression and execution to concrete entities and heuristic rules. Current result: ```text classification: ENTITY_NO_TICK_MATRIX_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS event_count: 519 entity_row_count: 12 observed_entity_row_count: 12 entity_suppression_row_count: 9 suppressed_count: 250 aggregate_no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.481696 aggregate_entity_suppression_coverage_ratio: 0.75 error_count: 0 warning_count: 35 native_matrix_clean: true ``` Scope result: ```text canonical: 512 events, 6 entity rows, 246 suppressions, 35 legacy warnings native: 7 events, 6 entity rows, 4 suppressions, 0 warnings, clean ``` This hardens no-tick at the actor layer. The system no longer only claims suppression globally; it shows which entities suppressed, which entities executed, which rules were involved and whether the proof/authority path was clean. ### 17. Suppression ledger The suppression ledger treats every non-execution as proof-backed avoided work. Current result: ```text classification: SUPPRESSION_LEDGER_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS event_count: 519 suppressed_count: 250 estimated_avoided_execution_count: 250 proof_valid_count: 250 proof_coverage_ratio: 1.0 below_threshold_suppression_count: 74 above_threshold_suppression_count: 176 aggregate_no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.481696 error_count: 0 warning_count: 176 native_suppression_clean: true ``` Scope result: ```text canonical: 512 events, 246 suppressions, 176 legacy threshold warnings native: 7 events, 4 suppressions, 0 warnings, clean ``` This hardens the efficiency claim. PNVA now distinguishes execution, suppression and avoided execution as auditable ledger entries. Legacy above-threshold suppressions remain visible as migration warnings; native suppression must remain proof-backed and below threshold. ### 18. Sovereign robustness gate The sovereign robustness gate collapses no-tick, logs, heuristics, entities, proof coverage, native cleanliness and legacy debt into one production-readiness decision. Current result: ```text classification: SOVEREIGN_ROBUSTNESS_GATE_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS readiness_level: R2_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_QUARANTINED robustness_score: 97 / 100 event_count: 519 suppressed_count: 250 no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.481696 native_clean_signal_count: 8 / 8 legacy_debt_count: 35 blocker_count: 0 ``` This closes the readiness gap. PNVA now has one high-level gate that says whether the release is production-evidence ready, whether native runtime behavior is clean, and what legacy debt still needs migration. ### 19. R3 migration plan The R3 migration planner converts the remaining readiness debt into a concrete release backlog. Current result: ```text classification: R3_MIGRATION_PLAN_READY current_readiness_level: R2_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_QUARANTINED target_readiness_level: R3_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_FREE current_robustness_score: 97 / 100 target_robustness_score: 100 / 100 source_event_count: 519 native_clean_signal_count: 8 / 8 primary_blocking_debt_count: 35 migration_action_count: 6 raw_migration_signal_count: 903 primary_required_remaining_count: 716 estimated_r3_candidate: false blocker_count: 0 ``` The plan is intentionally honest: it does not rename R2 as R3. It says the native path is clean today, then lists the precise work needed before claiming a legacy-free R3 release. ### 20. Authority migration ledger The authority migration ledger converts the primary R3 authority debt into concrete entity/action targets. Current result: ```text classification: AUTHORITY_MIGRATION_LEDGER_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS source_event_count: 519 candidate_event_count: 35 canonical_low_authority_strong_count: 35 native_low_authority_strong_count: 0 entity_candidate_count: 1 action_candidate_count: 3 event_type_candidate_count: 1 mapped_candidate_count: 35 unmapped_candidate_count: 0 migration_coverage_ratio: 1.0 proof_coverage_ratio: 1.0 warning_count: 35 error_count: 0 ``` Dominant target: ```text entity_id: entity_4c3ade60ea78 event_type: cuda_slot_scan dominant_action: RESIZE_BATCH dominant_action_count: 32 native_target_rules: adaptive_threshold, field_scheduler, power_orchestrator ``` This makes R3-A1 executable. The remaining H0 strong legacy decisions are no longer a vague warning; they are a bounded migration ledger with full proof coverage and zero native low-authority strong debt. ### 21. R3 authority projection The R3 authority projection turns the 35 mapped H0 authority candidates into a native hard-authority candidate sample before runtime replacement. Current result: ```text classification: R3_AUTHORITY_PROJECTION_READY source_candidate_count: 35 ledger_candidate_count: 35 projected_event_count: 70 projected_native_event_count: 70 projected_precheck_count: 35 projected_commit_count: 35 projected_strong_decision_count: 35 projected_low_authority_strong_count: 0 projected_no_tick_suppression_count: 35 projected_no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.5 proof_coverage_ratio: 1.0 entity_count: 1 replay: REPLAY_VALID policy: SOVEREIGN_POLICY_READY no_tick: SOVEREIGN_NO_TICK_READY ``` This makes the migration path testable without rewriting historical evidence. The old H0 warnings stay intact; the projected sample shows what the native R3 authority replacement must emit: precheck observe events, hard-authority commit events, proof-valid replay, strict policy readiness and measurable no-tick suppression. ### 22. R3 cutover gate The R3 cutover gate separates native replacement contract readiness from final runtime approval. Current result: ```text classification: R3_CUTOVER_APPROVED contract_ready: true cutover_approved: true legacy_free_claim_allowed: true fresh_runtime_evidence_present: true authority_candidate_count: 35 projected_event_count: 70 projected_precheck_count: 35 projected_commit_count: 35 projected_low_authority_strong_count: 0 remaining_runtime_replacement_count: 0 runtime_blocker_count: 0 contract_score: 100 ``` This prevents premature R3 claims and now records the approved state: the contract is ready, fresh runtime-emitted `pnva.event.v1` evidence is present, downstream validators pass and no runtime replacement remains pending. ### 23. R3 runtime capture matrix The R3 runtime capture matrix converts the remaining runtime replacement work into explicit entity/action/no-tick slots. Current result: ```text classification: R3_RUNTIME_CAPTURE_MATRIX_COMPLETE capture_contract_ready: true runtime_capture_complete: true runtime_capture_approved: true capture_slot_count: 35 verified_runtime_slot_count: 35 pending_slot_count: 0 required_runtime_event_count: 70 required_no_tick_precheck_count: 35 required_collapse_commit_count: 35 projection_pair_count: 35 projection_pair_coverage_ratio: 1.0 entity_target_count: 1 action_target_count: 3 target_rule_count: 4 ``` This turns the final R3 step into a concrete capture contract and verifies the accepted sample: one no-tick precheck and one native commit for each slot, without `proof.projection=true`, with H2 or stronger commit authority. ### 24. R3 runtime evidence guard The R3 runtime evidence guard protects the intake boundary for future runtime logs. Current result: ```text classification: R3_RUNTIME_EVIDENCE_ACCEPTED intake_guard_ready: true runtime_evidence_present: true runtime_evidence_approved: true runtime_acceptance_complete: true capture_slot_count: 35 required_runtime_event_count: 70 accepted_slot_count: 35 pending_slot_count: 0 rejected_event_count: 0 duplicate_event_rejection_count: 0 duplicate_proof_hash_rejection_count: 0 duplicate_proof_ref_rejection_count: 0 source_line_monotonicity_rejection_count: 0 causal_chain_slot_collision_rejection_count: 0 no_tick_pair_integrity_count: 35 no_tick_pair_failure_count: 0 same_source_file_no_tick_pair_count: 35 state_continuity_no_tick_pair_count: 35 negative_control_detected_count: 63 negative_control_count: 63 positive_control_passed_count: 6 positive_control_count: 6 positive_controls_fixture_only: true ``` This prevents a weak R3 completion claim. Final runtime evidence must be fresh, native, no-tick paired, same-chain strictly timestamp-ordered, causal-chain unique per slot, same-source-file paired, state-continuous from precheck to commit, JSONL-line ordered, source-line ordered, monotonic per source file, public-basename sourced, exact event-type bound, exact-cardinality per slot, exact-count by declared runtime requirement, duplicate-free across events/proof hashes/proof refs/source locations, entity-bound by ID and type, slot-bound, source-format-bound, source-sanitized, proof-clean, proof-hash bound to event identity, proof-ref bound to slot/role, gate-delta consistent, heuristic-clean, risk-flag clean on prechecks and commits, and H2+ authorized before it can be accepted by the cutover path. ### 25. R3 runtime instrumentation plan The R3 runtime instrumentation plan converts the remaining slots into concrete emitter contracts. Current result: ```text classification: R3_RUNTIME_INSTRUMENTATION_PLAN_READY instrumentation_plan_ready: true runtime_evidence_present: true runtime_evidence_approved: true capture_slot_count: 35 entity_target_count: 1 action_contract_count: 3 required_runtime_event_count: 70 required_no_tick_precheck_count: 35 required_collapse_commit_count: 35 event_template_count: 6 mandatory_field_count: 28 negative_control_detected_count: 63 positive_control_passed_count: 6 ``` Action contracts: ```text RESIZE_BATCH: 32 slots, 64 runtime events COOLDOWN_GPU: 2 slots, 4 runtime events EXECUTE: 1 slot, 2 runtime events ``` This makes R3 operational instead of informal. The final runtime must emit native no-tick prechecks and native commits with entity identity and type, same-chain causal pair identity, causal-chain uniqueness per slot, original event mapping, R3 runtime slot identity, exact event types, exactly one precheck and one commit per slot, strict proof hashes bound to event identity, runtime proof refs bound to slot/role, known non-legacy heuristic rules, known and unique risk flags on both prechecks and commits, unique event IDs, unique public source filenames, same-source-file no-tick pairs, precheck-to-commit state continuity, unique source locations, strictly increasing timestamps, ordered JSONL records, ordered source lines without per-file regression, `proof.native=true`, `source.format=native_pnva_event_v1`, `source.sanitized=true` and `proof.projection=false`. ### 26. R3 runtime contract validation The R3 runtime contract validator checks that the capture matrix, evidence guard and instrumentation plan agree before final capture. Current result: ```text classification: R3_RUNTIME_CONTRACT_VALIDATED_READY contract_validation_ready: true runtime_evidence_present: true runtime_evidence_approved: true capture_slot_count: 35 action_contract_count: 3 required_runtime_event_count: 70 event_template_count: 6 mandatory_field_count: 28 negative_control_detected_count: 63 positive_control_passed_count: 6 enforced_control_count: 59 contract_check_count: 315 failure_count: 0 ``` This closes a contract drift risk. The R3 slot IDs, original event IDs, causal-chain uniqueness per slot, guard controls, no-tick precheck templates, commit templates, exact role state transitions, exact event-type binding, exact pair cardinality, exact runtime event count, native proof markers, source file public-basename policy, same-source no-tick pair policy, precheck-to-commit state continuity, source location uniqueness, JSONL-line order, source-line order, per-file source-line monotonicity, source sanitization, proof identity binding and native source format agree as one validated contract. ### 27. Sovereign evolution ledger The sovereign evolution ledger consolidates no-tick evidence, log integrity, heuristic authority, entity attribution, controlled legacy warnings and R3 runtime readiness into one release dashboard. Current result: ```text classification: PNVA_SOVEREIGN_EVOLUTION_LEDGER_R3_READY sovereign_evolution_score: 98.37 current_readiness_level: R2_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_QUARANTINED target_readiness_level: R3_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_FREE evidence_integrity_ready: true no_tick_ready: true native_clean_path: true r3_preparation_ready: true r3_runtime_evidence_present: true r3_runtime_evidence_approved: true r3_cutover_approved: true r3_runtime_capture_coverage_percent: 100.0 runtime_pending_slot_count: 0 runtime_required_event_count: 70 runtime_contract_check_count: 315 runtime_contract_failure_count: 0 runtime_positive_control_passed_count: 6 runtime_mandatory_field_count: 28 runtime_enforced_control_count: 59 controlled_warning_count: 1232 blocker_count: 0 priority_action_count: 4 ``` This makes the release state explicit. The current PNVA package keeps historical legacy warnings visible, while the R3 slot-bound native runtime sample has zero pending slots, accepted runtime evidence and approved cutover. ### 28. Sovereign evidence attestation The evidence attestor binds the public package into one machine-readable record. Current result: ```text classification: PNVA_SOVEREIGN_EVIDENCE_ATTESTED artifact_count: 48 failure_count: 0 ``` The attestation computes: ```text evidence_hash ``` This hash changes if any tracked artifact changes its file hash, classification or pass flag. It gives PNVA a single citation anchor for the public evidence package. The sovereign audit consumes this attestation and is intentionally kept outside the attestation hash seed to avoid circular evidence hashing. ### 29. Adversarial validation The adversarial validator adds negative controls. Current result: ```text classification: ADVERSARIAL_VALIDATION_PASS test_count: 7 detected_count: 7 failure_count: 0 ``` Controlled mutations: ```text PROOF_HASH_MISMATCH LOW_AUTHORITY_STRONG_DECISION EVENT_ENTITY_NOT_IN_CATALOG RELATION_TARGET_NOT_IN_CATALOG DUPLICATE_EVENT_IDS CHAIN_HASH_DRIFT JSON_PARSE_ERROR ``` This closes a critical proof gap. PNVA validators now demonstrate not only that valid evidence passes, but also that corrupted proof, weak authority, invalid topology, duplicate identity, order tampering and malformed JSON are rejected or exposed. ### 30. Entity and heuristic maturity The entity/heuristic maturity auditor scores whether PNVA decisions are attributable to actors and rules. Current result: ```text classification: ENTITY_HEURISTIC_MATURITY_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS maturity_score: 94.59 total_event_count: 519 total_suppressed_count: 250 aggregate_no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.481696 aggregate_hard_authority_ratio: 0.884868 canonical_low_authority_legacy_count: 35 native_low_authority_legacy_count: 0 error_count: 0 warning_count: 35 ``` Canonical scope: ```text classification: ENTITY_HEURISTIC_MATURITY_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS event_count: 512 maturity_score: 94.17 errors: 0 warnings: 35 ``` Native scope: ```text classification: ENTITY_HEURISTIC_MATURITY_READY event_count: 7 maturity_score: 95.0 errors: 0 warnings: 0 ``` This makes the next no-tick evolution concrete: reduce legacy authority in future runtime events while preserving old evidence honestly. ### 31. Semantic consistency guard The semantic consistency guard checks whether public reports agree with each other. Current result: ```text classification: SEMANTIC_CONSISTENCY_READY check_count: 331 error_count: 0 warning_count: 0 ``` Consistency checks include: ```text Manifest summary vs source reports canonical event counts across bridge, replay, no-tick, policy, graph and proof-chain native event counts across emitter, no-tick, policy, graph and proof-chain maturity aggregate math attestation artifact count audit summary vs attestation and maturity threshold/decision calibration vs Manifest and audit decision trace index vs Manifest and audit heuristic influence map vs Manifest and audit entity no-tick matrix vs Manifest and audit suppression ledger vs Manifest and audit sovereign robustness gate vs Manifest and audit R3 migration plan vs Manifest and audit authority migration ledger vs Manifest, R3 plan, policy, heuristic influence, attestation and audit R3 authority projection vs Manifest, authority migration ledger, replay, policy, no-tick, attestation and audit R3 cutover gate vs Manifest, authority migration ledger, R3 authority projection, attestation and audit R3 runtime capture matrix vs Manifest, authority migration ledger, R3 cutover gate, attestation and audit R3 runtime evidence guard vs Manifest, R3 runtime capture matrix, attestation and audit R3 runtime instrumentation plan vs Manifest, R3 runtime capture matrix, R3 runtime evidence guard, attestation and audit R3 runtime contract validation vs Manifest, R3 runtime capture matrix, R3 runtime evidence guard, R3 runtime instrumentation plan, attestation and audit sovereign evolution ledger vs Manifest, no-tick maturity, R3 runtime capture matrix, R3 runtime contract validation, attestation and audit Manifest file list existence ``` This closes a publication risk: reports can no longer drift silently while still appearing valid individually. ### 32. Reproducibility guard The reproducibility guard reruns the evidence commands and compares stable fields against the published package. Current result: ```text classification: REPRODUCIBILITY_READY command_count: 40 comparison_count: 445 failure_count: 0 command_failure_count: 0 comparison_failure_count: 0 ``` Reproduced areas: ```text replay no-tick invariants native event emission sovereign policy proof-chain sealing causal graph audit schema contract validation causal chronology guard tension-decision calibration decision trace index heuristic influence map entity no-tick matrix suppression ledger sovereign robustness gate R3 migration plan authority migration ledger R3 authority projection R3 cutover gate R3 runtime capture matrix R3 runtime evidence guard R3 runtime instrumentation plan R3 runtime contract validation sovereign evolution ledger adversarial validation entity and heuristic maturity evidence attestation semantic consistency ``` This closes the method gap: the public evidence is now not only stored and cross-consistent, but regenerable from source commands with zero stable-field drift. ## Next Engineering Recommendations 1. Add schema version to every new JSONL event. 2. Add `entity_id` and `causal_chain_id` to every runtime event. 3. Add thermal pressure provenance when `thermal_pressure` is high but sensor temperature/power are zero. 4. Normalize `event` vs `kind` into the canonical envelope. 5. Treat `RESIZE_BATCH` ratio as a pressure metric, not as failure. 6. Keep raw logs private and publish only sanitized summaries. 7. Add rollback reference to every H3/H4 heuristic action. 8. Use `tools/pnva_canonical_bridge.py` before publishing any future event sample. 9. Compare future runtimes against `pnva.event.v1`, not against ad hoc log keys. 10. Use `tools/pnva_replay_validator.py` to validate every canonical event sample before release. 11. Use `tools/pnva_no_tick_invariant_analyzer.py` to prove causal suppression, entity coverage and heuristic visibility after replay. 12. Use `tools/pnva_native_event_emitter.py` as the reference pattern for new runtime emitters. 13. Use `tools/pnva_sovereign_policy_validator.py` to enforce H2/H3 authority for future strong decisions. 14. Use `tools/pnva_proof_chain_sealer.py` to seal event sequence order before publication. 15. Use `tools/pnva_causal_graph_auditor.py` to audit entity topology and causal relation flow. 16. Use `tools/pnva_schema_contract_validator.py` before attestation so event/entity envelope defects become release blockers. 17. Use `tools/pnva_causal_chronology_guard.py` before attestation so time remains an audited trace, not a blind driver. 18. Use `tools/pnva_tension_decision_calibrator.py` before attestation so threshold/decision drift is explicit. 19. Use `tools/pnva_decision_trace_index.py` before attestation so every event maps to entity, heuristics, tension and proof. 20. Use `tools/pnva_heuristic_influence_map.py` before attestation so rule authority and decision influence remain measurable. 21. Use `tools/pnva_entity_no_tick_matrix.py` before attestation so no-tick suppression is attributable by entity. 22. Use `tools/pnva_suppression_ledger.py` before attestation so avoided execution is proof-backed. 23. Use `tools/pnva_sovereign_robustness_gate.py` before attestation so native cleanliness and legacy debt collapse into one readiness decision. 24. Use `tools/pnva_r3_migration_planner.py` before attestation so R2 debt becomes a measurable R3 backlog. 25. Use `tools/pnva_authority_migration_ledger.py` before attestation so H0 strong legacy decisions become entity/action-specific native migration targets. 26. Use `tools/pnva_r3_authority_projection.py` before attestation so mapped H0 debt has native replay, policy and no-tick validation before runtime replacement. 27. Use `tools/pnva_r3_cutover_gate.py` before attestation so projection readiness and final runtime approval remain separate. 28. Use `tools/pnva_r3_runtime_capture_matrix.py` before attestation so every remaining runtime replacement is explicit by entity, action, heuristic and no-tick precheck. 29. Use `tools/pnva_r3_runtime_evidence_guard.py` before attestation so projected or weak runtime evidence is rejected before final cutover. 30. Use `tools/pnva_r3_runtime_instrumentation_plan.py` before final capture so every remaining runtime slot has an emitter contract, mandatory field set and validation command path. 31. Use `tools/pnva_r3_runtime_contract_validator.py` before attestation so matrix, guard and instrumentation remain one coherent runtime contract. 32. Use `tools/pnva_sovereign_evolution_ledger.py` before attestation so no-tick, logs, heuristics, entities and R3 runtime readiness collapse into one honest release ledger. 33. Use `tools/pnva_evidence_attestor.py` to publish one aggregate evidence hash for each release. 34. Use `tools/pnva_adversarial_validator.py` before release so validator failures are proven, not assumed. 35. Use `tools/pnva_entity_heuristic_maturity.py` to choose hardening targets by entity, heuristic and authority. 36. Use `tools/pnva_semantic_consistency_guard.py` after attestation to block cross-report drift. 37. Use `tools/pnva_reproducibility_guard.py` after semantic consistency to prove source-command reproducibility. ## Sovereign Rule PNVA should never become a black box. Every gain must be traceable to a causal chain, and every reclassification must preserve the raw contradiction that made it necessary.