# PNVA Sovereign Logs, Entities And Heuristics Author: Gustavo de Aguiar Martins Project: PNVA-Core / Enygnalab / EnyOS Edition: Open Research / Production Evidence Edition, 2026 This document defines the next robust layer of PNVA-Core: canonical logs, explicit entities and auditable heuristics. The goal is not to change the already validated gates. The goal is to make future PNVA/no-tick evolution harder to break, easier to audit and safer to publish. ## 1. Core Finding The current PNVA laboratory already contains the essential runtime organs: - adaptive threshold; - ETEV guard; - Memory4D; - affinity routing; - power orchestration; - causal event logs; - heuristic logs; - proof gates; - sanitized public evidence. The next weakness is not lack of computation. The weakness is contract dispersion: different logs use different shapes, some events use `event`, others use `kind`, some proof summaries use `pass`, others use `overall_status`. That is normal in a research lab, but production sovereignty requires one canonical envelope. ## 2. Canonical Event Chain Every PNVA event should be representable as: ```text field -> event -> tension -> gate -> collapse/block -> action -> proof ``` The canonical event schema is: ```text schemas/pnva-event.schema.json ``` Minimum envelope: ```json { "schema_version": "pnva.event.v1", "event_id": "evt_20260505_000001", "timestamp": "2026-05-05T00:00:00Z", "causal_chain_id": "chain_runtime_001", "entity_id": "zano-entity-00", "entity_type": "worker", "event_type": "ETEV_GUARD_PASS", "field": { "state_before": "observing", "state_after": "candidate", "phi": 0.42, "gradient": 0.10, "hessian": 0.02 }, "tension": { "score": 0.74, "threshold": 0.70, "margin": 0.01, "gate_delta": 0.03 }, "decision": { "kind": "collapse", "action": "EXECUTE", "reason": "signal_above_threshold", "confidence": 0.86 }, "heuristics": { "rules": ["adaptive_threshold", "etev_guard", "memory4d"], "risk_flags": [] }, "proof": { "proof_hash": "sha256:...", "proof_ref": "proofs/sanitized/prove-long-run-live-gate.json", "valid": true, "canonical": true } } ``` ## 3. Canonical Entity Model Every important actor must have an entity identity: ```text schemas/pnva-entity.schema.json ``` Entity types: ```text field event_source worker gate guard proof memory heuristic publication author ``` This prevents ambiguity. A worker, a gate, a proof and a publication page must not be mixed into the same conceptual bucket. ## 4. Heuristic Sovereignty A heuristic is allowed to act only when it can explain: ```text input signal normalization threshold margin decision reason confidence proof reference fallback mode ``` Heuristics must be classified: | Class | Meaning | Production Rule | | --- | --- | --- | | H0 | observation only | never executes | | H1 | advisory | emits recommendation | | H2 | guarded action | requires threshold and proof | | H3 | sovereign action | requires guard, rollback and proof | | H4 | reclassification | requires explicit criteria and backup | No heuristic should silently mutate production state without proof. ## 5. No-Tick Robustness Rules PNVA/no-tick should preserve these invariants: ```text do not wake without observable cause do not execute without threshold do not reclassify without criteria do not publish raw logs without sanitization do not hide transients do not confuse local validation with universal proof ``` ## 6. Entity Health Each runtime entity should expose: ```text entity_id entity_type state last_seen confidence capabilities risk_flags proof_ref ``` Recommended health flags: ```text MISSING_SCHEMA_VERSION MISSING_ENTITY_ID MISSING_CAUSAL_CHAIN MISSING_PROOF_REF THERMAL_PRESSURE_WITHOUT_SENSOR_SOURCE FINAL_TRANSIENT_RECLASSIFIED RAW_FAIL_CANONICAL_PASS LOW_EVENT_DIVERSITY HIGH_RESIZE_BATCH_RATIO STALE_JOB_PRESSURE ``` These are not automatic failures. They are early warning signals. ## 7. Current Lab Reading Local log inspection showed: ```text pnva_decisions.jsonl: 17525 lines, 0 JSON parse errors pnva-miner-events.jsonl: 9427 lines, 0 JSON parse errors pnva_causal_events.jsonl: 12735 sealed causal records zano_pnva_heuristics.jsonl: 1845 heuristic records with veonic fields ``` Dominant mining action: ```text RESIZE_BATCH ``` Dominant pressure reason: ```text cpu_host_thermal_taper ``` Engineering interpretation: The runtime is conservative and event-aware. The next improvement is not to force aggression; it is to record thermal pressure provenance and separate thermal entity state from generic field tension. ## 8. Next Production Upgrade Add a bridge layer: ```text legacy log -> canonical pnva.event.v1 envelope -> sovereign audit report ``` This makes old logs useful without rewriting the validated runtime. ## 9. No-Tick Invariant Layer After canonicalization and replay, run the no-tick invariant analyzer: ```text canonical pnva.event.v1 -> replay validation -> no-tick invariant report ``` This layer proves that PNVA is not merely executing less. It proves that suppressed actions are also represented as auditable decisions. Current public invariant report: ```text reports/pnva-no-tick-invariants-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text SOVEREIGN_NO_TICK_READY ``` Core numbers: ```text event_count: 512 collapse_count: 266 observe_count: 213 block_count: 33 suppressed_count: 246 no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.4805 guard_consistency_ratio: 1.0 proof_integrity_ratio: 1.0 ``` Production interpretation: PNVA/no-tick becomes stronger when it can prove not only why it acted, but also why it refused to act. ## 10. Native Event Emission The bridge keeps legacy logs useful. The native emitter defines the production direction: ```text runtime -> pnva.event.v1 -> replay -> no-tick invariants -> sovereign audit ``` Native events must include: ```text source.format = native_pnva_event_v1 proof.native = true schema_version = pnva.event.v1 ``` Current native demo: ```text reports/pnva-native-events-demo-2026-05-05.jsonl reports/pnva-native-entity-catalog-demo-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-native-emitter-summary-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text NATIVE_EMITTER_READY ``` Production interpretation: New PNVA runtimes should not wait for post-processing to become auditable. They should emit canonical events at the moment of observation, collapse, block, proof or suppression. ## 11. Sovereign Policy Validation The policy layer checks whether the decision had enough authority to act. Strong decisions: ```text collapse block prove reclassify ``` Required policy for strong decisions: ```text valid proof entity in catalog H2/H3/H4 authority ``` Legacy exception: Old converted logs may contain strong decisions with only `legacy_observer`. These are not hidden and not silently promoted. They are preserved as warnings: ```text SOVEREIGN_POLICY_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Native expectation: New events must be clean: ```text SOVEREIGN_POLICY_READY ``` This creates a migration path: preserve old evidence honestly, but demand stronger authority from every new runtime event. ## 12. Proof-Chain Sealing After replay, invariants and policy validation, seal the event sequence: ```text pnva.event.v1 sequence -> proof chain -> final_chain_hash ``` The proof chain computes: ```text event_hash = sha256(canonical_event_json) chain_hash = sha256(index, previous_chain_hash, event_id, event_hash) ``` This makes event order externally auditable. If one event is changed, removed, inserted or reordered, the final chain hash changes. Current canonical seal: ```text PROOF_CHAIN_SEALED 512 events 0 bad proofs ``` Current native seal: ```text PROOF_CHAIN_SEALED 7 events 0 bad proofs ``` Production interpretation: PNVA evidence should not only be valid event by event. It should be sealed as a sequence. ## 13. Causal Graph Audit Entity sovereignty requires topology. After event validation and sequence sealing, build the causal graph: ```text entities + relations + causal_chain_id -> causal graph ``` The graph audit checks: ```text event entities exist in catalog relation targets exist in catalog observed entities are connected by chain or relation edges graph_hash is stable ``` Current canonical graph: ```text CAUSAL_GRAPH_READY 512 events 6 observed entities 68 relation edges 230 chain edges ``` Current native graph: ```text CAUSAL_GRAPH_READY 7 events 6 observed entities 2 relation edges 6 chain edges ``` Production interpretation: PNVA should expose not only decisions, but the topology of the field that made those decisions possible. ## 14. Schema Contract Validation After graph topology, validate the structural envelope itself: ```text pnva.event.v1 + pnva.entity.v1 -> schema contract validation ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-schema-contract-validation-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text SCHEMA_CONTRACT_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Current result: ```text event_count: 519 entity_count: 12 relation_count: 70 heuristic_rule_count: 9 error_count: 0 warning_count: 341 ``` Production interpretation: PNVA evidence becomes stronger when every public event and entity can be checked for schema version, identity, causal chain, tension, decision, heuristic context, proof and sanitized source. The canonical legacy sample keeps its type-consolidation warnings visible. The native emitter scope has zero contract warnings. ## 15. Causal Chronology Guard After structure validation, audit time as evidence: ```text pnva.event.v1 timestamps + causal_chain_id -> causal chronology ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-causal-chronology-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text CAUSAL_CHRONOLOGY_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Current result: ```text event_count: 519 chain_count: 15 global_backward_count: 1 error_count: 0 warning_count: 2 native_chronology_clean: true ``` Production interpretation: PNVA/no-tick does not ignore time. It refuses to let time be the blind execution motor. Time remains a proof dimension: event order, chain order, gaps and batch compaction must be visible. The canonical legacy bridge keeps one temporal reset and timestamp compaction as warnings. The native path is monotonic and clean. ## 16. Tension Decision Calibration After chronology, validate whether the decision agrees with the field tension: ```text score + threshold + gate_delta + guard event -> decision calibration ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-tension-decision-calibration-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text TENSION_DECISION_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Current result: ```text event_count: 519 error_count: 0 warning_count: 384 native_calibration_clean: true legacy_calibration_warning_count: 384 ``` Production interpretation: PNVA/no-tick is stronger when every `collapse`, `block` and `observe` can be explained by the tension threshold that produced it. The canonical bridge preserves 384 legacy calibration warnings instead of hiding them. The native runtime path is calibrated clean: collapse/prove are positive decisions, block/observe are below-threshold decisions. ## 17. Decision Trace Index After tension-decision calibration, index every decision as a traceable public record: ```text event + entity + heuristic rules + authority + tension + proof -> decision trace ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-decision-trace-index-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text DECISION_TRACE_INDEX_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Current result: ```text event_count: 519 traced_event_count: 519 trace_coverage_ratio: 1.0 entity_coverage_ratio: 1.0 proof_coverage_ratio: 1.0 heuristic_coverage_ratio: 1.0 causal_chain_coverage_ratio: 1.0 tension_coverage_ratio: 1.0 hard_authority_event_count: 367 low_authority_trace_count: 152 error_count: 0 warning_count: 152 native_trace_clean: true ``` Production interpretation: PNVA/no-tick becomes easier to review when every event can be followed from event ID to entity, rule, authority, tension and proof. The canonical bridge preserves 152 low-authority trace warnings as legacy evidence. The native trace path is complete and clean. ## 18. Heuristic Influence Map After every decision is traceable, measure how each heuristic rule influences decisions and entities: ```text rule + authority + decision mix + entity reach + proof coverage -> heuristic influence ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-heuristic-influence-map-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text HEURISTIC_INFLUENCE_MAP_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Current result: ```text event_count: 519 heuristic_rule_count: 9 heuristic_coverage_ratio: 1.0 proof_event_coverage_ratio: 1.0 influence_edge_count: 1136 hard_authority_edge_count: 776 low_authority_edge_count: 360 low_authority_strong_edge_count: 164 uncompensated_low_authority_strong_event_count: 35 hard_authority_edge_ratio: 0.683099 error_count: 0 warning_count: 70 native_influence_clean: true ``` Production interpretation: PNVA/no-tick becomes more governable when heuristic intelligence is not opaque. The map shows which rules carry collapse, block, observe and prove decisions, and where legacy low-authority influence remains. The native path has zero influence warnings and keeps strong decisions covered by hard authority. ## 19. Entity No-Tick Matrix After tension-decision calibration, make no-tick attributable by entity: ```text entity + heuristic + authority + suppression/execution + proof -> no-tick matrix ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-entity-no-tick-matrix-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text ENTITY_NO_TICK_MATRIX_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Current result: ```text event_count: 519 entity_row_count: 12 observed_entity_row_count: 12 entity_suppression_row_count: 9 suppressed_count: 250 aggregate_no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.481696 aggregate_entity_suppression_coverage_ratio: 0.75 error_count: 0 warning_count: 35 native_matrix_clean: true ``` Production interpretation: PNVA/no-tick becomes more robust when non-execution is not only counted globally, but attributed to an entity, heuristic rule, authority level and proof. The matrix shows that 9 of 12 observed entity rows participated in suppression. The canonical bridge keeps 35 low-authority legacy warnings visible; the native matrix is clean. ## 20. Suppression Ledger After the entity matrix attributes suppression to actors, make every avoided execution auditable: ```text suppressed event + entity + rules + proof + threshold delta -> avoided execution ledger ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-suppression-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text SUPPRESSION_LEDGER_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Current result: ```text event_count: 519 suppressed_count: 250 estimated_avoided_execution_count: 250 proof_valid_count: 250 proof_coverage_ratio: 1.0 below_threshold_suppression_count: 74 above_threshold_suppression_count: 176 aggregate_no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.481696 error_count: 0 warning_count: 176 native_suppression_clean: true ``` Production interpretation: PNVA/no-tick becomes academically stronger when non-execution is treated as a first-class proof artifact. The current ledger shows 250 proof-backed suppressions, interpreted as 250 avoided executions. The native path has no above-threshold suppression drift; the 176 warnings remain visible as legacy bridge evidence instead of being erased. ## 21. Sovereign Robustness Gate After suppression, entity and heuristic evidence is visible, collapse the release posture into one readiness gate: ```text no-tick + traces + heuristics + entities + proof + native cleanliness + legacy debt -> robustness gate ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-sovereign-robustness-gate-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text SOVEREIGN_ROBUSTNESS_GATE_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Current result: ```text readiness_level: R2_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_QUARANTINED robustness_score: 97 / 100 event_count: 519 suppressed_count: 250 no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.481696 native_clean_signal_count: 8 / 8 legacy_debt_count: 35 blocker_count: 0 ``` Production interpretation: This is the strongest honest summary of the current package: native PNVA evidence is clean; historical canonical evidence still carries bounded migration debt. New production events should target `R3_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_FREE` by removing the remaining 35 low-authority strong legacy decisions. ## 22. R3 Migration Plan After the robustness gate, convert remaining debt into a measurable migration backlog: ```text robustness debt + heuristic influence debt + suppression debt + schema warnings -> R3 migration plan ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-r3-migration-plan-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text R3_MIGRATION_PLAN_READY ``` Current result: ```text current_readiness_level: R2_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_QUARANTINED target_readiness_level: R3_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_FREE current_robustness_score: 97 / 100 target_robustness_score: 100 / 100 source_event_count: 519 native_clean_signal_count: 8 / 8 primary_blocking_debt_count: 35 migration_action_count: 6 raw_migration_signal_count: 903 primary_required_remaining_count: 716 estimated_r3_candidate: false blocker_count: 0 ``` Production interpretation: The migration planner stays conservative: it preserves the historical R2 legacy-quarantined baseline and names the original debt. The downstream R3 runtime layers then close the mapped slot-bound replacement sample with native evidence, while the historical warnings remain visible instead of being deleted. ## 23. Authority Migration Ledger After the R3 plan, convert the primary authority debt into entity/action-level targets: ```text R3 primary debt + policy warnings + influence warnings -> authority migration ledger ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-authority-migration-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text AUTHORITY_MIGRATION_LEDGER_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Current result: ```text source_event_count: 519 candidate_event_count: 35 canonical_low_authority_strong_count: 35 native_low_authority_strong_count: 0 entity_candidate_count: 1 action_candidate_count: 3 event_type_candidate_count: 1 mapped_candidate_count: 35 unmapped_candidate_count: 0 migration_coverage_ratio: 1.0 proof_coverage_ratio: 1.0 warning_count: 35 error_count: 0 ``` Dominant migration target: ```text entity_id: entity_4c3ade60ea78 event_type: cuda_slot_scan dominant_action: RESIZE_BATCH dominant_action_count: 32 ``` Native replacement rule mix: ```text adaptive_threshold: 35 field_scheduler: 35 power_orchestrator: 2 ``` Production interpretation: The package still preserves the 35 historical H0 strong decisions as warnings. The ledger makes them actionable: future `cuda_slot_scan` strong decisions should be emitted as native `pnva.event.v1` with `adaptive_threshold`, `field_scheduler` and, for cooldown cases, `power_orchestrator` authority. ## 24. R3 Authority Projection After the authority migration ledger maps the H0 strong debt, project that debt into a native hard-authority candidate sample: ```text authority migration ledger -> native precheck events + native commit events -> replay + policy + no-tick validation ``` Current report set: ```text reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-summary-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-events-2026-05-05.jsonl reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-entities-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-replay-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-policy-2026-05-05.json reports/pnva-r3-authority-projection-no-tick-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text R3_AUTHORITY_PROJECTION_READY ``` Current result: ```text source_candidate_count: 35 ledger_candidate_count: 35 projected_event_count: 70 projected_native_event_count: 70 projected_precheck_count: 35 projected_commit_count: 35 projected_strong_decision_count: 35 projected_low_authority_strong_count: 0 projected_no_tick_suppression_count: 35 projected_no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.5 proof_coverage_ratio: 1.0 entity_count: 1 replay: REPLAY_VALID policy: SOVEREIGN_POLICY_READY no_tick: SOVEREIGN_NO_TICK_READY ``` Production interpretation: This does not rewrite the historical H0 evidence. It creates the native implementation contract for R3: every mapped H0 candidate gets a no-action precheck and a hard-authority collapse commit, then passes replay, policy and no-tick validation before runtime replacement. ## 25. R3 Cutover Gate After the projection is valid, separate contract readiness from final runtime approval: ```text R3 authority projection + replay + policy + no-tick -> cutover gate ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-r3-cutover-gate-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text R3_CUTOVER_APPROVED ``` Current result: ```text contract_ready: true cutover_approved: true legacy_free_claim_allowed: true fresh_runtime_evidence_present: true authority_candidate_count: 35 projected_event_count: 70 projected_precheck_count: 35 projected_commit_count: 35 projected_low_authority_strong_count: 0 remaining_runtime_replacement_count: 0 runtime_blocker_count: 0 contract_score: 100 ``` Production interpretation: The cutover gate now approves the slot-bound native runtime sample. The contract is ready, runtime evidence is present, downstream replay/policy/no-tick/proof-chain checks pass, and no runtime replacement remains pending. ## 26. R3 Runtime Capture Matrix After the cutover gate blocks premature R3 completion, convert the remaining runtime work into exact capture slots: ```text R3 cutover gate + authority ledger + projection pairs -> runtime capture matrix ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-r3-runtime-capture-matrix-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text R3_RUNTIME_CAPTURE_MATRIX_COMPLETE ``` Current result: ```text capture_contract_ready: true runtime_capture_complete: true runtime_capture_approved: true capture_slot_count: 35 verified_runtime_slot_count: 35 pending_slot_count: 0 required_runtime_event_count: 70 required_no_tick_precheck_count: 35 required_collapse_commit_count: 35 projection_pair_count: 35 projection_pair_coverage_ratio: 1.0 entity_target_count: 1 action_target_count: 3 target_rule_count: 4 ``` Production interpretation: The matrix verifies the runtime capture shape. Each R3 replacement has an entity, action, target heuristic set, native no-tick precheck, native commit and proof rule, with all 35 slots covered by the accepted runtime sample. ## 27. R3 Runtime Evidence Guard After the capture matrix defines the required slots, protect the intake boundary for fresh runtime logs: ```text runtime capture matrix + fresh JSONL candidate -> evidence guard -> accept or reject ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-r3-runtime-evidence-guard-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text R3_RUNTIME_EVIDENCE_ACCEPTED ``` Current result: ```text intake_guard_ready: true runtime_evidence_present: true runtime_evidence_approved: true runtime_acceptance_complete: true capture_slot_count: 35 required_runtime_event_count: 70 accepted_slot_count: 35 pending_slot_count: 0 rejected_event_count: 0 duplicate_event_rejection_count: 0 duplicate_proof_hash_rejection_count: 0 duplicate_proof_ref_rejection_count: 0 source_line_monotonicity_rejection_count: 0 no_tick_pair_integrity_count: 35 no_tick_pair_failure_count: 0 same_source_file_no_tick_pair_count: 35 state_continuity_no_tick_pair_count: 35 negative_control_detected_count: 63 negative_control_count: 63 positive_control_passed_count: 6 positive_control_count: 6 positive_controls_fixture_only: true ``` Production interpretation: The guard makes the future R3 runtime harder to fake. It rejects projected proofs, missing or invalid timestamps, duplicate event IDs, duplicate proof hashes, duplicate proof refs, duplicate source locations, causal-chain reuse across different runtime slots, unsafe source filenames with local paths or traversal markers, mismatched source files inside a no-tick pair, broken precheck-to-commit state continuity, source-line regression, invalid proof hash format, content-unbound proof hashes, proof refs with the wrong slot/role, wrong event types, extra runtime events, missing field state, missing or inconsistent gate delta, non-finite tension values, positive no-tick precheck deltas, negative commit deltas, missing or mismatched entity IDs and entity types, missing causal chains, broken no-tick pair chains, commit-before-or-equal-to-precheck timestamp ordering, commit-before-precheck JSONL ordering, commit source-line ordering failures, missing proof hashes, missing native proof flags, invalid or unsanitized native source format, missing or mismatched R3 slot identity, original-event mismatches, low-authority commits, legacy, unknown or duplicate heuristic rules, malformed/unknown/duplicate risk flags, missing precheck or commit target heuristic rules, missing precheck or commit target risk flags, action mismatches and prechecks that execute instead of proving no-tick suppression. It also proves six fixture-only positive controls so the intake boundary is strict without becoming unusable. This improves robustness without disturbing the current 24h and production PASS evidence. ## 28. R3 Runtime Instrumentation Plan After the evidence guard protects intake, keep the accepted slots bound to explicit emitter work: ```text capture slots + guard rules -> action contracts + event templates + validation commands ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-r3-runtime-instrumentation-plan-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text R3_RUNTIME_INSTRUMENTATION_PLAN_READY ``` Current result: ```text instrumentation_plan_ready: true runtime_evidence_present: true runtime_evidence_approved: true capture_slot_count: 35 entity_target_count: 1 action_contract_count: 3 required_runtime_event_count: 70 required_no_tick_precheck_count: 35 required_collapse_commit_count: 35 event_template_count: 6 mandatory_field_count: 28 negative_control_detected_count: 63 positive_control_passed_count: 6 ``` Production interpretation: The plan turns R3 from an abstract backlog into explicit runtime engineering. The current targets are `RESIZE_BATCH`, `COOLDOWN_GPU` and `EXECUTE`, each requiring native no-tick precheck and native commit events with `timestamp`, parseable ISO-8601 time, `field.state_before`, `field.state_after`, precheck `field.state_after=suppressed`, commit `field.state_after=committed`, commit `field.state_before` equal to precheck `field.state_after`, `heuristics.risk_flags`, `tension.gate_delta`, `gate_delta = score - threshold`, exact event type binding, exactly one precheck and one commit per slot, exact runtime event count, `proof.projection=false`, `proof.native=true`, `source.format=native_pnva_event_v1`, same-source no-tick pair emission, monotonic JSONL/source order without per-file regression, public-basename source filenames, `source.sanitized=true`, `tension.components.original_event_id`, `tension.components.r3_runtime_slot_id`, entity identity and type, causal chain identity unique to one slot, strict proof hash bound to event identity, runtime proof refs, unique proof refs, unique event IDs, known non-legacy heuristic rules, known/unique risk flags on prechecks and commits and same-chain precheck/commit ordering. This makes PNVA more sovereign because final evidence must be emitted by the runtime contract in physical log order, not inferred from projection. ## 29. R3 Runtime Contract Validation After the instrumentation plan exists, validate the contract itself: ```text capture matrix + evidence guard + instrumentation plan -> contract validation ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-r3-runtime-contract-validation-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text R3_RUNTIME_CONTRACT_VALIDATED_READY ``` Current result: ```text contract_validation_ready: true runtime_evidence_present: true runtime_evidence_approved: true capture_slot_count: 35 action_contract_count: 3 required_runtime_event_count: 70 event_template_count: 6 mandatory_field_count: 28 negative_control_detected_count: 63 positive_control_passed_count: 6 enforced_control_count: 59 contract_check_count: 315 failure_count: 0 ``` Production interpretation: The validator prevents contract drift after runtime capture. It proves the matrix slot IDs, original event IDs, causal-chain uniqueness per slot, guard enforced controls, instrumentation templates, no-tick prechecks, commit actions, exact event types, exact pair cardinality, exact runtime event count, native proof markers, proof-ref role binding, proof-hash identity and source-location binding, tension gate-delta policy, source file public-basename policy, same-source no-tick pair policy, precheck-to-commit state continuity, source location uniqueness, JSONL-line order, source-line order, per-file source-line monotonicity and source sanitization still agree as one system. ## 30. Sovereign Evolution Ledger After the R3 contract is validated, collapse the whole evolution state into one release ledger: ```text no-tick + logs + heuristics + entities + R3 runtime contract -> evolution ledger ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-sovereign-evolution-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_SOVEREIGN_EVOLUTION_LEDGER_R3_READY ``` Current result: ```text sovereign_evolution_score: 98.37 current_readiness_level: R2_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_QUARANTINED target_readiness_level: R3_NATIVE_CLEAN_LEGACY_FREE evidence_integrity_ready: true no_tick_ready: true native_clean_path: true r3_preparation_ready: true r3_runtime_evidence_present: true r3_runtime_evidence_approved: true r3_cutover_approved: true r3_runtime_capture_coverage_percent: 100.0 runtime_pending_slot_count: 0 runtime_required_event_count: 70 runtime_contract_check_count: 315 runtime_contract_failure_count: 0 runtime_positive_control_passed_count: 6 runtime_mandatory_field_count: 28 runtime_enforced_control_count: 59 controlled_warning_count: 1232 blocker_count: 0 priority_action_count: 4 ``` Production interpretation: The ledger turns the PNVA evolution into a single operational dashboard. It says what is strong now, what is still controlled legacy, and why the slot-bound native runtime sample is accepted for R3: 70 required events, 35 verified slots, zero pending slots, zero runtime blockers and accepted cutover. ## 31. Sovereign Evidence Attestation After all validators run, bind the evidence package: ```text proofs + events + replay + invariants + policy + chains + graphs + schema contract + chronology + tension decision + decision trace + heuristic influence + entity matrix + suppression ledger + robustness gate + R3 migration plan + authority migration ledger + R3 authority projection + R3 cutover gate + R3 runtime capture matrix + R3 runtime evidence guard + R3 runtime instrumentation plan + R3 runtime contract validation + sovereign evolution ledger -> evidence_hash ``` The attestation lists each tracked artifact with: ```text path sha256 classification pass flag artifact counters ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_SOVEREIGN_EVIDENCE_ATTESTED ``` Current package: ```text 48 tracked artifacts 0 failures ``` Production interpretation: PNVA evidence should be cited by a single aggregate hash, while still preserving every underlying proof file for independent review. The sovereign audit is not included inside that aggregate hash because it consumes the attestation. This avoids circular hashing. ## 32. Adversarial Validation A sovereign validator must prove that it rejects bad evidence, not only that it accepts clean evidence. The adversarial validation layer runs controlled mutations against the public validators: ```text proof hash tamper low-authority strong decision missing event entity bad relation target duplicate event id event order tamper malformed JSON line ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-adversarial-validation-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text ADVERSARIAL_VALIDATION_PASS ``` Current result: ```text 7 detected mutations over 7 tests ``` Production interpretation: PNVA evidence becomes more sovereign when validators have negative controls. A `PASS` is stronger when the same tooling can also show why corrupted proof, weak authority, invalid topology, duplicate identity, reordered sequence or malformed JSON does not pass silently. ## 33. Entity And Heuristic Maturity After validation and adversarial controls, score the maturity of the actors and rules: ```text entities + heuristics + authority + no-tick suppression + proof coverage -> maturity score ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-entity-heuristic-maturity-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text ENTITY_HEURISTIC_MATURITY_READY_WITH_LEGACY_WARNINGS ``` Current aggregate: ```text maturity_score: 94.59 total_event_count: 519 total_suppressed_count: 250 aggregate_no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.481696 aggregate_hard_authority_ratio: 0.884868 canonical_low_authority_legacy_count: 35 native_low_authority_legacy_count: 0 error_count: 0 warning_count: 35 ``` Production interpretation: The canonical legacy bridge preserves 35 low-authority strong decisions as warnings. The native runtime path has zero low-authority legacy warnings. This creates a clean migration rule: old evidence stays honest; new PNVA runtimes must emit native events with H2/H3 authority. ## 34. Semantic Consistency Guard After all evidence reports are generated, check whether they agree as a system: ```text manifest + reports + audit + attestation -> semantic consistency ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-semantic-consistency-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text SEMANTIC_CONSISTENCY_READY ``` Current result: ```text check_count: 331 error_count: 0 warning_count: 0 ``` Production interpretation: PNVA evidence should not pass only as isolated files. The release is stronger when event counts, trace coverage, heuristic influence, suppression counts, avoided-execution counts, strong-decision counts, graph counts, chronology, tension-decision calibration, decision trace index, entity no-tick matrix, suppression ledger, robustness gate, R3 migration plan, authority migration ledger, R3 authority projection, R3 cutover gate, R3 runtime capture matrix, R3 runtime evidence guard, R3 runtime instrumentation plan, R3 runtime contract validation, sovereign evolution ledger, maturity math, Manifest metadata, audit summaries and attestation hashes all agree. The semantic consistency report is not included in the attestation hash seed because it consumes the attestation. ## 35. Reproducibility Guard After semantic consistency, rerun the current tools and compare stable fields against published reports: ```text source commands -> temporary reports -> stable-field comparison -> reproducibility result ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-reproducibility-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text REPRODUCIBILITY_READY ``` Current result: ```text command_count: 40 comparison_count: 445 failure_count: 0 command_failure_count: 0 comparison_failure_count: 0 ``` Production interpretation: PNVA evidence becomes stronger when reports are not only internally consistent, but reproducible from the repository commands. This checks that replay, no-tick invariants, native emission, policy, proof-chain, graph, schema contract, chronology, tension-decision calibration, decision trace index, heuristic influence map, entity no-tick matrix, suppression ledger, robustness gate, R3 migration plan, authority migration ledger, R3 authority projection, R3 cutover gate, R3 runtime capture matrix, R3 runtime evidence guard, R3 runtime instrumentation plan, R3 runtime contract validation, sovereign evolution ledger, adversarial validation, maturity, attestation and semantic consistency can be regenerated without stable-field drift. The reproducibility report is not included in the attestation hash seed because it consumes the attestation. This keeps the evidence graph acyclic. ## 36. Root Sovereignty Guard After reproducibility, collapse runtime evidence, entities, heuristics, no-tick pairs, traceability, proof integrity and publication hygiene into one root-level guard: ```text runtime events + entity catalog + no-tick pairs + traceability matrix + cutover + ledger + attestation + semantic + reproducibility + audit -> root readiness ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-sovereignty-guard-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_SOVEREIGNTY_GUARD_READY ``` Current result: ```text root_score: 100.0 check_count: 27 failure_count: 0 event_count: 70 slot_count: 35 entity_count: 1 ``` Production interpretation: The root guard is the final coherence check for the public package. It verifies that each R3 slot has one no-tick precheck and one native commit, the events are entity-bound, source-sanitized, non-projected, proof-hash bound, H2+ by policy, traceable by slot matrix and accepted by replay, policy, no-tick, proof-chain, cutover, ledger, attestation, semantic consistency, reproducibility and sovereign audit. The root guard is intentionally outside the attestation hash seed because it consumes attestation, audit and reproducibility. ## 37. Root Causal Intelligence After the root guard, turn no-tick logs, heuristic authority, entity coverage and proof integrity into a deterministic intelligence score: ```text canonical no-tick + native no-tick + R3 runtime no-tick + entities + heuristics + root guard -> causal intelligence ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-causal-intelligence-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_CAUSAL_INTELLIGENCE_READY ``` Current result: ```text root_causal_intelligence_score: 100.0 failure_count: 0 aggregate_no_tick_event_count: 589 aggregate_no_tick_suppressed_count: 285 aggregate_no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.483871 runtime_verified_slot_count: 35 runtime_pending_slot_count: 0 runtime_projected_proof_count: 0 ``` Production interpretation: This layer makes PNVA smarter without making it vague. It measures causal suppression, runtime pair closure, entity binding, heuristic authority, native proof quality and public hygiene. Historical canonical warnings remain visible as migration context; the R3 runtime path is measured separately as native-clean. ## 38. Root Traceability Matrix After causal intelligence, expose the root laboratory table for no-tick, entities, heuristics and proofs: ```text runtime slots + no-tick prechecks + collapse commits + entity catalog + heuristics + proof refs -> traceability matrix ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-traceability-matrix-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_TRACEABILITY_MATRIX_READY ``` Current result: ```text root_traceability_score: 100.0 check_count: 8 failure_count: 0 slot_count: 35 valid_slot_count: 35 invalid_slot_count: 0 proof_hash_unique_count: 70 proof_ref_unique_count: 70 no_tick_suppression_ratio: 0.5 runtime_guard_negative_controls: 63/63 root_traceability_hash: sha256:f6bd17b7e2103e6a3f224b3be267cbd835ad548cfa5b5aa04245817ef91feb7d ``` Production interpretation: The matrix makes the PNVA root evidence directly inspectable. Every accepted runtime slot has one no-tick precheck, one collapse commit, one entity identity, known heuristic rules, native non-projected proof refs and proof hashes. Any invalid slot row becomes a root blocker. ## 39. Root Adversarial Sentry After traceability, prove that root evidence corruption does not pass silently: ```text clean root evidence -> root PASS mutated runtime evidence -> root FAIL ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-adversarial-sentry-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_ADVERSARIAL_SENTRY_PASS ``` Current result: ```text clean_control_pass: true test_count: 8 detected_count: 8 failure_count: 0 ``` Controlled mutations: ```text proof.projection=true missing entity_id broken no-tick state continuity weak runtime authority unsafe source path duplicate event_id positive gate_delta on no-tick precheck legacy_observer heuristic injection ``` Production interpretation: This layer makes the root package harder to fake. It mutates only temporary copies of the runtime evidence, then requires both `PNVA_ROOT_SOVEREIGNTY_GUARD_FAIL` and `PNVA_ROOT_CAUSAL_INTELLIGENCE_NEEDS_HARDENING` on corrupted input. ## 40. Root Release Seal After green-path validation, causal intelligence, traceability and adversarial rejection, seal the final public root package: ```text root guard + causal intelligence + traceability matrix + adversarial sentry + ledger + cutover + runtime guard + semantic + reproducibility + attestation + audit -> root release hash ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-release-seal-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_RELEASE_SEALED ``` Current result: ```text sealed_artifact_count: 11 failure_count: 0 root_score: 100.0 root_causal_intelligence_score: 100.0 root_adversarial_detection_ratio: 8/8 runtime_accepted_slots: 35 runtime_pending_slots: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The root release seal is the final citation anchor. It is separate from the evidence attestation hash and intentionally outside the attestation seed. If any root report, audit, reproducibility, semantic consistency, cutover or runtime guard artifact changes, this hash changes. ## 41. Root Release Verifier After sealing the final root package, verify the seal from outside the seal itself: ```text root release seal + sealed artifacts + SHA256SUMS + claim boundaries -> verified release ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-release-verifier-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_RELEASE_VERIFIED ``` Current result: ```text verification_count: 9 failure_count: 0 sealed_artifact_count: 11 checksum_missing_count: 0 checksum_mismatch_count: 0 stable_hash_mismatch_count: 0 classification_mismatch_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The verifier makes the final seal challengeable. It recomputes the root release hash, confirms artifact classifications, checks checksum coverage and proves that the public claim boundary still rejects unsupported claims such as universal performance, private deployment validation, hardware energy proof without counters or physical-particle proof. ## 42. Root Claim Boundary Guard After verifying the release seal, scan the public language before posting, publishing or indexing: ```text root seal + root verifier + public docs + limits + llms.txt -> claim boundary guard ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-claim-boundary-guard-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_CLAIM_BOUNDARY_GUARD_READY ``` Current result: ```text claim_boundary_score: 100.0 check_count: 7 failure_count: 0 scanned_file_count: 90 high_risk_occurrence_count: 48 unbounded_high_risk_occurrence_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The claim boundary guard makes public recognition safer. It checks that phrases about universal proof, physical particles, private deployment, hardware energy and medical/legal scope appear only inside explicit limitation language. This keeps PNVA ambitious but academically defensible. ## 43. Root Publication Gate After claim boundary validation, close the public release package for repository publication and indexing: ```text root reports + Manifest + SHA256SUMS + robots + sitemap + llms + public pages -> publication gate ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-publication-gate-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_PUBLICATION_GATE_READY ``` Current result: ```text publication_score: 100.0 check_count: 9 failure_count: 0 manifest_file_count: 258 checksum_count: 257 sitemap_url_count: 83 path_leak_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The publication gate is the last public-readiness check. It requires root reports, checksum closure, discovery metadata, llms boundaries, canonical public files and zero local path leaks before public posting. ## 44. Root Dependency Graph After publication readiness, expose the evidence package as a directed proof graph: ```text public contract + proof gates + event validators + entity ledgers + R3 runtime + root guards + seal + verifier + claim boundary + publication gate -> dependency graph ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-dependency-graph-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_DEPENDENCY_GRAPH_READY ``` Current result: ```text dependency_score: 100.0 check_count: 8 failure_count: 0 node_count: 49 edge_count: 104 phase_count: 11 missing_artifact_count: 0 readiness_failure_count: 0 cycle_count: 0 phase_violation_count: 0 unreachable_node_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The dependency graph makes the PNVA evidence chain easier to audit. It proves that the public package is not only a set of PASS reports; it is an ordered acyclic proof chain where every node reaches the final publication gate. ## 45. Root Observability Index After dependency closure, generate one laboratory dashboard for no-tick, logs, entities, heuristics and root gates: ```text no-tick metrics + event streams + entity catalogs + heuristic influence + runtime slots + root gates -> observability index ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-observability-index-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_OBSERVABILITY_INDEX_READY ``` Current result: ```text observability_score: 100.0 check_count: 8 failure_count: 0 aggregate_event_count: 589 aggregate_suppressed_count: 285 aggregate_suppression_ratio: 0.483871 entity_catalog_rows: 13 runtime_accepted_slots: 35 runtime_pending_slots: 0 runtime_rejected_events: 0 heuristic_rule_count: 9 influence_edge_count: 1136 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The observability index is the root laboratory view. It proves that PASS status can be read through event counts, suppression counts, proof hashes, entity catalogs, heuristic influence, runtime slots and public boundary checks. ## 46. Root Invariant Firewall After observability is visible, lock the root invariants so future changes cannot silently regress the proof package: ```text observability + dependency graph + publication boundary + runtime contract + adversarial controls -> invariant firewall ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-invariant-firewall-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_INVARIANT_FIREWALL_READY ``` Current result: ```text firewall_score: 100.0 check_count: 12 failure_count: 0 event_stream_count: 3 entity_catalog_count: 3 entity_catalog_rows: 13 aggregate_event_count: 589 aggregate_suppressed_count: 285 runtime_accepted_slots: 35 runtime_pending_slots: 0 runtime_rejected_events: 0 runtime_no_tick_pair_failures: 0 root_dependency_cycles: 0 publication_path_leaks: 0 unbounded_high_risk_claims: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The invariant firewall turns PASS into a guarded contract. Logs, entities, heuristics, runtime slots, proof identity and publication boundaries must remain coherent for future changes to pass. ## 47. Root Regression Sentinel After the invariant firewall passes, watch for metric drift: ```text firewall + observability + root baseline + publication hygiene -> regression sentinel ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-regression-sentinel-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_REGRESSION_SENTINEL_READY ``` Current result: ```text regression_score: 100.0 check_count: 5 failure_count: 0 monitored_metric_count: 36 stable_metric_count: 36 regressed_metric_count: 0 aggregate_event_count_min: 589 aggregate_suppressed_count_min: 285 aggregate_suppression_ratio_range: 0.45..0.70 runtime_r3_projected_count_max: 0 entity_catalog_rows_min: 13 heuristic_rule_count_min: 9 runtime_accepted_slot_count_min: 35 publication_path_leak_count_max: 0 unbounded_high_risk_occurrence_count_max: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The sentinel turns the current baseline into a future-watch contract. A future improvement should not reduce no-tick proof, event identity, entity coverage, heuristic coverage, runtime acceptance or public hygiene. ## 48. Root Proof Theorem Ledger After PASS reports exist, convert them into explicit proof cards: ```text claim + criteria + evidence + boundary + dependencies -> theorem ledger ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-proof-theorem-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_PROOF_THEOREM_LEDGER_READY ``` Current result: ```text theorem_score: 100.0 check_count: 4 failure_count: 0 theorem_count: 12 proven_theorem_count: 12 failed_theorem_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The theorem ledger is the public academic bridge. It turns logs and gates into citable technical statements without expanding the root seal or claiming more than the evidence supports. ## 49. Root Evolution Governor After theorem cards exist, govern future improvements through invariant-locked evolution cards: ```text locked invariants + controlled debts + safe evolution cards -> evolution governor ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-evolution-governor-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_EVOLUTION_GOVERNOR_READY ``` Current result: ```text governor_score: 100.0 check_count: 6 failure_count: 0 invariant_count: 22 invariant_failure_count: 0 controlled_debt_count: 5 evolution_card_count: 8 safe_to_plan_count: 8 blocked_card_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The governor is the safety layer for future PNVA growth. It allows expansion only when no-tick budget, runtime native proof, entity coverage, heuristic coverage, negative controls, theorem cards, claim boundary and path hygiene remain intact. ## 50. Root Heuristic Weight Ledger After evolution is governed, expose public heuristic weights: ```text rule authority + proof coverage + suppression behavior + entity links -> public audit weight ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-heuristic-weight-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_HEURISTIC_WEIGHT_LEDGER_READY ``` Current result: ```text weight_ledger_score: 100.0 check_count: 9 failure_count: 0 rule_count: 9 ready_rule_count: 8 controlled_legacy_rule_count: 1 blocked_rule_count: 0 total_rule_edge_count: 1350 proof_complete: true projection_clean: true root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The heuristic weight ledger makes rule intelligence visible without exposing private tuning. A PNVA rule becomes public-ready when it has proof coverage, projection-free evidence, authority classification, no-tick behavior and entity links. ## 51. Root Entity Capability Ledger After heuristic weights are visible, bind entities to capability and readiness: ```text catalog + event coverage + proof coverage + no-tick behavior + heuristic links -> entity capability ledger ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-entity-capability-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_ENTITY_CAPABILITY_LEDGER_READY ``` Current result: ```text entity_capability_score: 100.0 check_count: 12 failure_count: 0 entity_row_count: 13 scope_count: 3 profile_event_count: 589 capability_edge_count: 25 r3_runtime_ready_count: 1 native_ready_count: 6 controlled_canonical_count: 6 blocked_entity_count: 0 proof_complete: true projection_clean: true root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The entity capability ledger makes the field governable. It shows which entities are R3 runtime-ready, native-ready or controlled canonical evidence, and blocks future expansion unless every entity has catalog, proof coverage and projection-free behavior. ## 52. Root Field Topology Ledger After entity capability is visible, expose the graph between entities, rules and no-tick decisions: ```text entities + heuristic rules + decisions + proof coverage -> root field topology ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-field-topology-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_FIELD_TOPOLOGY_LEDGER_READY ``` Current result: ```text field_topology_score: 100.0 check_count: 13 failure_count: 0 entity_node_count: 13 rule_node_count: 9 event_count: 589 rule_event_edge_count: 1350 entity_rule_edge_count: 38 entity_decision_edge_count: 17 rule_decision_edge_count: 20 topology_density: 0.324786 r3_edge_count: 4 legacy_edge_count: 5 blocked_edge_count: 0 orphan_entity_count: 0 orphan_rule_count: 0 unruled_event_count: 0 unknown_entity_event_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The field topology ledger makes the PNVA root graph governable. It shows how entities connect to heuristic rules, how rules connect to decisions, and where R3-ready, native-ready, controlled canonical and controlled legacy edges live. Future expansion should not enter runtime unless this graph remains proof-covered, projection-free and free of orphan or blocked edges. ## 53. Root No-Tick Causal Contract After topology is visible, bind logs, entities, heuristic rules and threshold behavior into one no-tick contract: ```text events + proof hashes + entities + rules + suppression + threshold behavior -> no-tick causal contract ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-no-tick-causal-contract-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_NO_TICK_CAUSAL_CONTRACT_READY ``` Current result: ```text causal_contract_score: 100.0 check_count: 15 failure_count: 0 event_count: 589 collapse_count: 303 observe_count: 250 block_count: 35 prove_count: 1 suppressed_count: 285 suppression_ratio: 0.483871 proof_valid_count: 589 projection_event_count: 0 strict_native_r3_event_count: 77 strict_threshold_violation_count: 0 canonical_legacy_threshold_exception_count: 294 r3_chain_count: 35 r3_pair_failure_count: 0 guard_contract_failure_count: 0 unknown_entity_count: 0 unknown_rule_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The no-tick causal contract makes the runtime discipline explicit. Native and R3 evidence must obey strict threshold behavior, while canonical legacy threshold exceptions remain accepted only as bounded historical evidence. This keeps the system honest: no-tick is proven by suppression, proof coverage, entity/rule closure and R3 precheck/commit pairs, not by vague claims. ## 54. Root Runtime Admission Controller After the no-tick causal contract passes, convert root evidence into an explicit admission decision: ```text contract + topology + entities + heuristics + invariants + regression + public boundary -> runtime admission ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-runtime-admission-controller-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_RUNTIME_ADMISSION_READY ``` Current result: ```text runtime_admission_score: 100.0 check_count: 10 failure_count: 0 admission_decision: ADMIT_RESTRICTED_ROOT_RUNTIME_PLANNING event_count: 589 suppressed_count: 285 suppression_ratio: 0.483871 strict_threshold_violation_count: 0 r3_chain_count: 35 r3_pair_failure_count: 0 entity_row_count: 13 blocked_entity_count: 0 rule_count: 9 blocked_rule_count: 0 entity_rule_edge_count: 38 blocked_edge_count: 0 controlled_debt_count: 5 safe_to_plan_count: 8 regressed_metric_count: 0 path_leak_count: 0 unbounded_high_risk_occurrence_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Allowed modes: ```text audit_only observe simulate restricted_native_event_ingest restricted_r3_precheck_commit planning_only_evolution ``` Denied modes: ```text unbounded_public_claims unsanitized_log_ingest private_threshold_publication unpaired_r3_runtime_events projected_runtime_evidence unknown_entity_or_rule_runtime hardware_energy_claim_without_counter_benchmark ``` Production interpretation: The admission controller makes future PNVA expansion explicit. New runtime evidence is allowed only when no-tick, topology, entity capability, heuristic weight, invariant firewall, regression sentinel, claim boundary and root hash stability remain clean. ## 55. Root Entity-Heuristic Admission Matrix After runtime admission passes, classify every entity-rule edge: ```text entity readiness + rule weight + proof coverage + topology + runtime admission -> edge admission status ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-entity-heuristic-admission-matrix-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_ENTITY_HEURISTIC_ADMISSION_MATRIX_READY ``` Current result: ```text admission_matrix_score: 100.0 check_count: 11 failure_count: 0 event_count: 589 rule_event_edge_count: 1350 entity_rule_edge_count: 38 admitted_r3_edge_count: 4 admitted_native_edge_count: 12 controlled_canonical_edge_count: 17 bounded_legacy_edge_count: 5 denied_edge_count: 0 unknown_entity_count: 0 unknown_rule_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The entity-heuristic admission matrix prevents invisible runtime growth. Every entity-rule edge must be R3-restricted, native-restricted, controlled canonical evidence, bounded legacy or denied. The current root has zero denied edges and zero unknown entities or rules. ## 56. Root Admission Negative Controls After the admission matrix passes, corrupt temporary evidence and require the admission chain to fail: ```text bad event -> contract fail -> admission blocked -> matrix fail ``` Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-admission-negative-controls-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_ADMISSION_NEGATIVE_CONTROLS_PASS ``` Current result: ```text clean_control_pass: true control_count: 8 detected_count: 8 undetected_count: 0 failure_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Mutations detected: ```text r3_gate_delta_inversion r3_unpaired_chain r3_unknown_entity r3_projected_proof r3_unknown_rule r3_duplicate_event_id r3_invalid_proof_hash native_source_path_leak ``` Production interpretation: The negative controls prove that the latest no-tick, admission and entity-heuristic layers are not accepting bad evidence silently. Clean evidence stays PASS. Corrupted evidence is blocked before it can become runtime growth. ## 57. Root Event Identity Ledger After negative controls pass, prove that public event streams have unique event and proof identity. Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-event-identity-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_EVENT_IDENTITY_LEDGER_READY ``` Current result: ```text event_identity_score: 100.0 check_count: 10 failure_count: 0 event_count: 589 event_id_count: 589 unique_event_id_count: 589 proof_hash_count: 589 unique_proof_hash_count: 589 entity_binding_count: 13 rule_count: 9 rule_event_edge_count: 1350 r3_chain_count: 35 r3_pair_failure_count: 0 native_count: 77 projected_event_count: 0 path_leak_count: 0 unbounded_high_risk_occurrence_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The event identity ledger protects the lowest public evidence layer. Every event has a unique event ID, unique proof hash, catalog-bound entity, bounded heuristic rules, valid tension fields and clean R3 precheck/commit pair shape. ## 58. Root Runtime Growth Budget After negative controls pass, future root evidence must grow by explicit budget instead of open-ended accumulation. Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-runtime-growth-budget-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_RUNTIME_GROWTH_BUDGET_READY ``` Current result: ```text growth_budget_score: 100.0 check_count: 10 failure_count: 0 event_count: 589 suppressed_count: 285 suppression_ratio: 0.483871 r3_chain_count: 35 entity_rule_edge_count: 38 denied_edge_count: 0 negative_control_count: 8 negative_detected_count: 8 regressed_metric_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Growth policy: ```text growth_mode: SMALL_BATCH_RESTRICTED max_new_events_per_batch: 118 max_new_r3_chains_per_batch: 7 max_new_entity_rule_edges_per_batch: 8 min_suppression_ratio: 0.45 max_suppression_ratio: 0.70 max_denied_edges: 0 max_unknown_entities: 0 max_unknown_rules: 0 max_projected_events: 0 ``` Production interpretation: The growth budget prevents the root PNVA system from becoming noisy as more evidence is added. The next batch must preserve no-tick suppression, R3 pair integrity, classified entity-rule edges, clean public boundaries, zero denied unknown projected events and negative-control detection. ## 59. Root Causal Mesh Ledger After the growth budget passes, the root evidence package must prove that each PASS report agrees with the others. Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-causal-mesh-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_CAUSAL_MESH_LEDGER_READY ``` Current result: ```text causal_mesh_score: 100.0 check_count: 10 failure_count: 0 event_count: 589 suppressed_count: 285 suppression_ratio: 0.483871 entity_count: 13 rule_count: 9 rule_event_edge_count: 1350 entity_rule_edge_count: 38 r3_chain_count: 35 proof_valid_count: 589 denied_edge_count: 0 unknown_entity_count: 0 unknown_rule_count: 0 manifest_file_count: 258 checksum_count: 257 path_leak_count: 0 unbounded_high_risk_occurrence_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The causal mesh ledger prevents isolated PASS reports from hiding drift. No-tick counts, entity counts, heuristic counts, entity-rule admission, R3 integrity, proof validity, growth budget and public boundary metrics must all agree before the root package is treated as coherent. ## 60. Root Efficiency Proof Ledger After the causal mesh passes, quantify the no-tick gain as proof-backed causal non-execution against a public event baseline. Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-efficiency-proof-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_EFFICIENCY_PROOF_LEDGER_READY ``` Current result: ```text efficiency_score: 100.0 check_count: 9 failure_count: 0 event_count: 589 baseline_event_action_count: 589 collapse_count: 303 suppressed_count: 285 prove_count: 1 observed_required_action_count: 304 avoided_action_count: 285 avoided_action_ratio: 0.483871 causal_execution_ratio: 0.514431 entity_row_count: 13 rule_row_count: 9 rule_event_edge_count: 1350 native_count: 77 projected_event_count: 0 strict_threshold_violation_count: 0 suppressed_proof_failure_count: 0 path_leak_count: 0 unbounded_high_risk_occurrence_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The efficiency proof ledger turns the no-tick claim into a quantitative audit. PNVA avoids work only when the non-execution is attached to an event, proof hash, entity, heuristic rule and public boundary. ## 61. Root Equation Consistency Ledger After the efficiency proof passes, validate the operational equation behind tension and threshold decisions. Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-equation-consistency-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_EQUATION_CONSISTENCY_LEDGER_READY ``` Current result: ```text equation_consistency_score: 100.0 check_count: 9 failure_count: 0 event_count: 589 suppressed_count: 285 collapse_count: 303 prove_count: 1 avoided_action_ratio: 0.483871 formula_mismatch_count: 0 missing_equation_field_count: 0 strict_native_r3_violation_count: 0 canonical_legacy_warning_count: 384 canonical_legacy_threshold_exception_count: 294 entity_binding_count: 13 rule_count: 9 rule_event_edge_count: 1350 path_leak_count: 0 unbounded_high_risk_occurrence_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The equation consistency ledger makes the math auditable. It proves that gate deltas are derived from score, threshold and margin; that native/R3 threshold semantics are strict; and that canonical legacy warnings remain visible instead of being promoted to native-clean evidence. ## 62. Root Legacy Quarantine Ledger After equation consistency passes, quarantine canonical legacy warnings so they remain visible, attributed and bounded before any final readiness claim. Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-legacy-quarantine-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_LEGACY_QUARANTINE_LEDGER_READY ``` Current result: ```text legacy_quarantine_score: 100.0 check_count: 9 failure_count: 0 event_count: 589 legacy_warning_count: 384 canonical_legacy_warning_count: 384 native_legacy_warning_count: 0 runtime_r3_legacy_warning_count: 0 canonical_legacy_threshold_exception_count: 294 legacy_decision_counts: collapse=208, observe=176 legacy_entity_count: 4 legacy_rule_count: 7 bounded_legacy_edge_count: 5 controlled_legacy_rule_count: 1 denied_edge_count: 0 unknown_entity_count: 0 unknown_rule_count: 0 strict_native_r3_violation_count: 0 projected_event_count: 0 path_leak_count: 0 unbounded_high_risk_occurrence_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The legacy quarantine ledger makes the remaining debt honest. Canonical legacy events can still be studied, but they are not allowed to contaminate strict native/R3 runtime claims, unknown entities, denied edges or unbounded public claims. ## 63. Root Evidence Chronology Ledger After the legacy quarantine ledger passes, prove report order across the sealed core, post-seal ledgers and publication/growth checks. Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-evidence-chronology-ledger-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_EVIDENCE_CHRONOLOGY_LEDGER_READY ``` Current result: ```text chronology_score: 100.0 check_count: 11 failure_count: 0 report_count: 27 claim_scanned_file_count: 90 manifest_file_count: 258 checksum_count: 257 mesh_event_count: 589 mesh_suppressed_count: 285 mesh_entity_count: 13 mesh_rule_count: 9 path_leak_count: 0 unbounded_high_risk_occurrence_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The chronology ledger prevents valid reports from becoming an unordered pile of evidence. It proves that the sealed core is stable, post-seal reports cite the same root hash, and publication/growth checks extend the package without rewriting the sealed base. ## 64. Root Sovereign Readiness Gate After chronology passes, collapse the root system into one final readiness decision across no-tick logs, event identity, proof identity, entities, heuristics, efficiency, equation consistency, legacy quarantine, admission, growth, negative controls and publication hygiene. Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-sovereign-readiness-gate-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_SOVEREIGN_READINESS_GATE_PASS ``` Current result: ```text readiness_score: 100.0 check_count: 11 failure_count: 0 event_count: 589 suppressed_count: 285 suppression_ratio: 0.483871 avoided_action_count: 285 avoided_action_ratio: 0.483871 efficiency_score: 100.0 equation_consistency_score: 100.0 legacy_quarantine_score: 100.0 legacy_warning_count: 384 native_legacy_warning_count: 0 runtime_r3_legacy_warning_count: 0 bounded_legacy_edge_count: 5 controlled_legacy_rule_count: 1 formula_mismatch_count: 0 strict_native_r3_violation_count: 0 collapse_count: 303 observe_count: 250 block_count: 35 prove_count: 1 entity_count: 13 rule_count: 9 rule_event_edge_count: 1350 entity_rule_edge_count: 38 r3_chain_count: 35 proof_valid_count: 589 native_count: 77 projected_event_count: 0 admission_decision: ADMIT_RESTRICTED_ROOT_RUNTIME_PLANNING growth_mode: SMALL_BATCH_RESTRICTED negative_detected_count: 8 path_leak_count: 0 unbounded_high_risk_occurrence_count: 0 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The readiness gate is the compact final answer for root sovereignty: public evidence is coherent only when event identity, no-tick suppression, equation consistency, legacy quarantine, entity/rule mesh, proof coverage, growth policy, negative controls and publication boundaries pass together. ## 65. Root Validator Registry After the readiness gate passes, register every root validator across tool, report, document, Manifest, checksum, CI and public documentation. Current report: ```text reports/pnva-root-validator-registry-2026-05-05.json ``` Current classification: ```text PNVA_ROOT_VALIDATOR_REGISTRY_READY ``` Current result: ```text registry_score: 100.0 check_count: 8 failure_count: 0 registry_count: 30 manifest_file_count: 258 checksum_count: 257 workflow_registered_count: 30 public_doc_registered_count: 30 report_pass_count: 30 root_release_hash: sha256:97f5c3f379db838784f864c312778a3afabea50ebb30acfffe4f6da2c97b65fc ``` Production interpretation: The validator registry prevents silent disappearance of proof layers. A root validator must be visible in source, report, documentation, Manifest, checksum and CI before it counts as part of the sovereign package. ## 66. Public Safety Public repositories should expose: ```text sanitized proof summaries schemas audit reports architecture paper limits publication metadata ``` Public repositories should not expose: ```text raw local logs private thresholds private tuning personal system paths mining secrets tokens wallets host-specific automation ``` ## 67. Principle PNVA becomes sovereign when every action can answer: ```text who acted? what field changed? which tension crossed threshold? which heuristic decided? what proof sealed the decision? what rollback exists if this was wrong? ```